The True Cost of Owning a Toyota GR86

Cost example updated October 24, 2026

Start with the price you will actually pay

For a representative example, use a 2025 Toyota GR86 Premium with the six-speed manual at $33,000. That is Edmunds' starting price for the Premium coupe with the manual gearbox, including the destination charge (the delivery fee from the factory to the dealer). Two other sources land nearby but not on the same number, and the spread is stated rather than settled: SlashGear lists the Premium manual at $33,735 including a $1,135 destination fee, and Kelley Blue Book lists the Premium at $34,135. The example uses the lowest of the three, so treat $33,000 as a starting point, not a quote. Trims run from the base coupe near $30,400 to the Hakone Edition at $35,270 with the manual, so replace this starting point with a written quote for the exact trim and gearbox you are considering.

The down payment does not make the GR86 cheaper; it changes how much you finance (borrow). With 10% down ($3,300), 8% APR (the yearly interest rate on the loan) and 60 months, and the 7% sales tax ($2,310) and $900 in title and dealer fees rolled into the loan, this example finances $32,910 at $667 a month, and the loan costs about $7,128 in interest over five years.

Fuel: premium gas is part of the deal

The Premium with the six-speed manual is rated 22 mpg combined (20 city, 26 highway), and it requires premium unleaded gas, regular gas is not the cheaper option here, it is the wrong fuel. At 12,000 miles a year that is about 545 gallons annually, roughly $2,825 a year, $14,127 over five years at $5.18 a gallon for premium, the national average reported for October 22, 2026. A second snapshot from October 4, 2026 put premium at $5.27, so the fuel line moves with the pump: every 10 cents a gallon is about $273 over five years at this mileage. The automatic version is rated 24 mpg combined (21 city, 30 highway), which would burn about $12,950 over five years at the same price, roughly $1,177 less, but the example uses the manual, so that saving does not apply here. The method behind that math is in the EV vs. gas guide: miles divided by mpg, times price, times years.

Depreciation is the pleasant surprise, with a big asterisk

Depreciation is the value a vehicle loses over time, and on the GR86 it is unusually small. iSeeCars comparison pages put the GR86's five-year value loss at about 24.9%, it keeps roughly 75.1% of its price. On a $33,000 purchase, that means a resale value near $24,783 after five years, about $8,217 of depreciation, roughly $137 a month.

The asterisk is large and stated rather than settled: iSeeCars' own best-resale-value ranking for coupes says the GR86 retains 88.5% of its value after five years, which would mean only 11.5% lost, $3,795 of depreciation and $29,205 resale, about $4,422 better than the figure used here. CarEdge lands close to the page figure at 76.94% retained, or about $7,610 of depreciation. The page uses the more cautious 24.9% figure so the example does not depend on the rosiest resale number, and you should still run a second scenario with resale 10% lower so the decision does not depend on an optimistic used market.

Insurance runs sports-car money

Full-coverage averages for a GR86 spread wide depending on the source: MoneyGeek puts the average at about $217 a month and the 2025 model at $229, while Compare.com puts full coverage at $324 a month and another Toyota rate table at $313. This example uses $230 a month, or $13,800 over five years, near MoneyGeek's 2025 figure and inside the published range, not at either end. Premiums depend heavily on the driver, ZIP code, coverage and insurer, and sports coupes are priced as higher risk than family cars, so get a quote on the exact trim with matching deductibles (what you pay first on a claim) and limits before treating any average as yours.

GR86 maintenance costs: small car, performance tires

Published maintenance signals for the GR86 point in different directions, so this page uses an allowance rather than a single published total. CarEdge puts GR86 maintenance at $314 a year through the first five years of ownership; RepairPal has no GR86-specific annual figure, but lists $672 a year for its near-identical twin, the Subaru BRZ; and owner-data write-ups put routine GR86 upkeep at $800 to $1,200 a year. This example allows $700 a year, or $3,500 all-in for maintenance and repairs. Toyota's included maintenance covers the first two years or 25,000 miles, which softens the early years but not the five-year picture.

The wear item to plan for is tires: the GR86 ships on performance tires, and a full set runs about $600 to $800, with one set inside five years a realistic plan at 60,000 miles. Brake pads are a $400 to $600 job over the same window on a daily-driven car. Track days change all of this, tires, pads and fluids wear far faster, so a car that sees regular track use needs a bigger allowance than the one used here.

The full five-year example

Every figure below comes from the site's own calculator math. The stated inputs are: 2025 Toyota GR86 Premium with the six-speed manual, $33,000 price, 10% down ($3,300), 8% APR, 60 months, 7% sales tax, $900 in title and dealer fees, 12,000 miles per year, 22 mpg, $5.18 per gallon premium, $230 per month insurance, $700 per year maintenance, $24,783 resale value after five years. The sales tax and fees are rolled into the loan, so the amount financed is $32,910.

• Depreciation: $8,217 ($33,000 minus $24,783 resale)
• Insurance: $13,800 ($230 x 60 months)
• Fuel: $14,127 (12,000 / 22 x $5.18 x 5 years)
• Maintenance: $3,500 ($700 x 5 years)
• Tax, fees and interest: $10,338 ($2,310 sales tax, $900 fees, $7,128 loan interest)

That totals roughly $49,982, or about $833 a month. Notice what that says about the $667 payment: on this coupe the payment is not the whole story, it is about 80% of the average month's true cost, and during the loan years the cash actually going out is the payment plus insurance, fuel and upkeep. Fuel and insurance, not depreciation, are the two biggest buckets here, the opposite of most new cars.

Formula

The five-year total is the sum of five buckets: depreciation, insurance, fuel, maintenance, and tax, fees and interest. Depreciation is the $33,000 price minus the $24,783 resale value after five years, which is $8,217. Insurance is $230 a month times 60 months, which is $13,800. Fuel is 12,000 miles a year divided by 22 miles per gallon, times $5.18 a gallon for premium, times 5 years, which is about $14,127. Maintenance is $700 a year times 5 years, which is $3,500. Tax, fees and interest is 7% sales tax on $33,000, which is $2,310, plus $900 in title and dealer fees, plus about $7,128 of loan interest, which is $10,338.

Added together, $8,217 plus $13,800 plus $14,127 plus $3,500 plus $10,338 equals $49,982, or about $833 a month. The amount financed is the $33,000 price plus $2,310 sales tax plus $900 in fees, minus the $3,300 down payment, which is $32,910. At 8% APR over 60 months, the payment on $32,910 is $667 a month, and the loan costs about $7,128 in interest over five years.

Why GR86 buyers should think past year five

Small sports coupes are often keepers, and that is where the economics can improve: the loan ends at year five, and the depreciation curve flattens. The costs that arrive in years six through ten are the wear-and-repair years, a second tire set, suspension work, and the out-of-warranty items no average can predict for one specific car. The keep it 10 years guide shows how to extend this same math honestly.

Shopping the GR86 against its near-identical twin, the Subaru BRZ, or a convertible like the Mazda MX-5 Miata? The Car Showdown runs any two vehicles through the same five buckets side by side. The BRZ shares the GR86's bones, but its prices, trims and resale are its own, run both cars' real numbers rather than assuming they match.

Buying in Texas? Texas adds its own layer to these numbers, a 6.25% sales tax, its own fees, and its own insurance market. See the true cost of a car in Texas.

Calculation transparency

Jurisdiction. United States. Sales tax, titling, registration and insurance rules are set by your state, so your exact numbers depend on where you buy and register the car. The 7% sales tax and $900 in fees in this example are planning figures, not any one state's actual rates.

Rules and time period. Five years, 12,000 miles a year, premium gas at $5.18 a gallon (AAA national average for premium, October 22, 2026), 8% APR, 60 months, 10% down. The resale value is a planning assumption, not a forecast.

Scope and limitations. Educational estimate only. Insurance and maintenance are planning figures, not quotes. Get a real quote for the same trim, coverage and loan before you decide.

Sources disagree on the GR86's five-year value loss: iSeeCars' comparison pages put it at 24.9 percent, which is the figure used here, while its dedicated resale page puts it at 11.5 percent and CarEdge puts retention at 76.9 percent, or 23.1 percent lost, so the 24.9 percent figure used here is kept as a planning assumption, not as a current reading. Edmunds' cost-to-own data puts five-year maintenance near $6,302 for the Premium with the manual, above the $3,500 allowance used here, while CarEdge puts it at $1,571 and owner write-ups at $800 to $1,200 a year, so the $700-a-year allowance used here is kept as printed.

Source links checked November 6, 2026. Figures: Edmunds 2025 GR86 Premium manual price, $33,000 including destination; EPA combined fuel economy, 22 mpg; MoneyGeek GR86 full-coverage average, $217 a month; Compare.com GR86 full-coverage average, $324 a month; CarEdge GR86 maintenance, $314 a year; AAA national average premium gas, $5.18 a gallon (October 22, 2026).

Primary sources: Edmunds, 2025 Toyota GR86; fueleconomy.gov, EPA fuel economy ratings; MoneyGeek, Toyota GR86 car insurance; Compare.com, Toyota GR86 car insurance; CarEdge, Toyota GR86 costs. How the numbers are calculated is written down on the methodology page, and every source is listed on the sources page.

Definitions

Depreciation. The value a car loses over time, the gap between what you pay and what it is worth later. On this page, the $33,000 price minus the $24,783 resale value after five years, which is $8,217.

Resale value. What the GR86 is worth after five years in this example, $24,783. A planning assumption, not a forecast.

APR. Annual percentage rate, the yearly interest rate on the loan. This example uses 8%.

Down payment. The cash paid up front. Here it is 10%, or $3,300.

Destination charge. The fee to ship the car to the dealer. The $33,000 example price includes destination.

Combined mpg. The EPA city and highway ratings blended into one figure. It is 22 for the Premium with the six-speed manual, 20 in the city and 26 on the highway.

Premium gas. Higher-octane unleaded gasoline. The GR86 requires premium gasoline, and this example budgets it at $5.18 a gallon.

Full coverage. Insurance that covers damage to your own car as well as damage you cause to others, and it is what a lender usually requires while a loan is open. This example uses $230 a month, or $13,800 over five years.

Questions people actually ask

How much does a Toyota GR86 cost per month?

About $833 a month over five years in the example above. The loan payment alone is $667 a month, insurance, fuel and upkeep sit on top of that during the loan years, and depreciation is the value the coupe loses rather than cash out the door.

How much does a Toyota GR86 cost to own for 5 years?

About $49,982 over five years for a 2025 Premium with the six-speed manual at $33,000, using the assumptions on this page: 10% down, 8% APR, 60 months, 7% sales tax, 12,000 miles a year and $5.18-a-gallon premium gas.

What is the gas mileage of a Toyota GR86?

The Premium with the six-speed manual is rated 22 mpg combined (20 city, 26 highway). The automatic version is rated 24 mpg combined (21 city, 30 highway). Premium unleaded gas is required.

How much does insurance cost for a Toyota GR86?

Published full-coverage averages range from about $217 to $324 a month depending on the source. This example uses $230 a month, or $13,800 over five years. Your own quote depends on the driver, ZIP code, coverage and insurer.

Does a Toyota GR86 hold its value?

Better than most cars, on the figures used here. iSeeCars comparison pages put the five-year loss at 24.9%, meaning the coupe keeps about 75.1% of its price, though iSeeCars' own best-resale ranking says it retains 88.5%, and CarEdge says 76.94%, so treat any of these figures as an estimate, not a promise.

Related: See the Mazda MX-5 Miata, the affordable roadster in the same spirit

Related: See the Ford Mustang and its five year cost

Related: See every model with a true cost page