Page published October 27, 2026
Get the free Car Buyer’s Cheat Sheet, 7 things to know before you sign anything. The numbers that matter, in plain English, on one page.
Join the Driveonomics email list. Occasional useful updates, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Everything else in the total is fixed in this example: gas $1,085 and upkeep $892. Only insurance moves, and it moves a lot, so the honest total is a range.
Formula
The first year total is built from four lines. The car itself, a $12,000 used car paid in full: $12,000. Insurance to add a teen to a family policy, for one year: $3,048 to $3,594. Gas, 7,624 miles at 30 miles per gallon and $4.27 a gallon: $1,085. Upkeep, 7,624 miles at about 11.7 cents a mile: $892. Low end: $12,000 plus $3,048 plus $1,085 plus $892 equals $17,025. High end: $12,000 plus $3,594 plus $1,085 plus $892 equals $17,571. The running costs alone, without the car, are $5,025 to $5,571 a year, or about $419 to $464 a month. After year one, the car is bought, so the ongoing figure is the running costs line, not the first year total.
Gas and upkeep come from the same mileage. The example teen drives 7,624 miles a year, the Federal Highway Administration teen mileage average. At 30 miles per gallon and $4.27 a gallon, the AAA national average on October 22, 2026, that is $1,085 of gas. At about 11.7 cents a mile, that is $892 of upkeep. Both lines are fixed in this example: only insurance moves.
Insurance is a range here, and the page says why rather than picking one. Two Driveonomics pages already disagree on this line. The first car page uses $3,048 a year, the 2026 MoneyGeek average for adding a teen to a family policy. The adding a teen page puts published 2026 averages at $3,435 to $3,594 a year, with $4,050 at age 16 falling to $3,105 at age 19. The range on this page runs from the MoneyGeek figure to the top of the published range, $3,048 to $3,594. Your own quote can land outside it in either direction, because state, insurer, car, coverage, and the teen age all move it. No single typical teen insurance figure is universal, and no page here should be read as if one were. Not in the total: sales tax and title, which vary by state; registration, paid at purchase and renewed each year at a state dependent amount; a repair fund on top of the $892 upkeep line for an older first car; and driver education, where required.
The assembly: what is in the total, and where each line comes from
| First year line | Low end | High end |
|---|---|---|
| The car itself, a $12,000 used car paid in full | $12,000 | $12,000 |
| Insurance to add a teen to a family policy, for one year | $3,048 | $3,594 |
| Gas, 7,624 miles at 30 miles per gallon and $4.27 a gallon | $1,085 | $1,085 |
| Upkeep, 7,624 miles at about 11.7 cents a mile | $892 | $892 |
| First year total | $17,025 | $17,571 |
$12,000 plus $3,048 plus $1,085 plus $892 equals $17,025. $12,000 plus $3,594 plus $1,085 plus $892 equals $17,571. The running costs alone, without the car, are $5,025 to $5,571 a year, or about $419 to $464 a month. After year one, the car is bought, so the ongoing figure is the running costs line, not the first year total.
Why insurance is a range here, and why that is honest
Two Driveonomics pages already disagree on this line, and this page says so rather than picking one. The first car page uses $3,048 a year, the 2026 MoneyGeek average for adding a teen to a family policy. The adding a teen page puts published 2026 averages at $3,435 to $3,594 a year, with $4,050 at age 16 falling to $3,105 at age 19. The range on this page runs from the MoneyGeek figure to the top of the published range, $3,048 to $3,594. Your own quote can land outside it in either direction, because state, insurer, car, coverage, and the teen age all move it. No single typical teen insurance figure is universal, and no page here should be read as if one were.
What is not in the total
Sales tax and title are one time costs that vary by state, so they are not in the first year total above; check your state fees before buying. Registration is paid at purchase and renewed each year, and its amount also varies by state. A repair fund sits on top of the $892 upkeep line for an older first car, since $892 is a planning figure from average mileage cost, not a promise that nothing big breaks. Driver education, if the state or school requires it, is also outside the total.
For the pieces separately, see how much a first car costs a teen and how much it costs to add a teen to car insurance. When the teen leaves for college, the decision changes: see first car for a college student. For safe used picks with costs, see the safest used cars and what they really cost.
Figures: car price, gas, and upkeep from the Driveonomics first car page: 7,624 miles a year from the Federal Highway Administration teen mileage average, gas at the AAA national average of $4.27 a gallon on October 22, 2026, upkeep at about 11.7 cents a mile. Insurance range from the MoneyGeek 2026 average and the published 2026 averages on the adding a teen page, as explained above.
Educational estimates only, not financial, tax, legal or insurance advice. Every figure on this page is a typical example worked from the inputs stated on the page, not a quote for a specific car, loan, or driver. Your rate, insurance, fuel use, and resale value will move your total. See Terms.
Calculation transparency
Scope. One worked example: a teen first year on a $12,000 used car paid in full, at 7,624 miles a year, with insurance shown as a range because no single typical teen insurance figure is universal.
Rules and time period. Car $12,000 paid in full; mileage 7,624 miles a year, the Federal Highway Administration teen mileage average; gas 30 miles per gallon at $4.27 a gallon, the AAA national average on October 22, 2026; upkeep about 11.7 cents a mile; insurance $3,048 to $3,594 a year, from the MoneyGeek 2026 average to the top of the published 2026 averages.
Scope and limitations. Educational estimate only. Sales tax and title, registration, a repair fund on top of the $892 upkeep line, and driver education are outside the total. The $892 upkeep line is a planning figure from average mileage cost, not a promise that nothing big breaks. Your own insurance quote can land outside the range in either direction. This page uses its own figures and does not import any other page teen figure. Prices vary by car, shop, and city. Get a written quote for your own car before you decide.
Source links checked November 6, 2026. Figures: Car price, gas, and upkeep from the Driveonomics first car page: 7,624 miles a year from the Federal Highway Administration teen mileage average, gas at the AAA national average of $4.27 a gallon on October 22, 2026, upkeep at about 11.7 cents a mile. Insurance range from the MoneyGeek 2026 average and the published 2026 averages on the adding a teen page, as explained above. The Federal Highway Administration mileage figure and the AAA gas figure are named only, not linked.
Primary sources: MoneyGeek, cheapest car insurance for teen drivers (2026); AAA Your Driving Costs 2026; How much does a first car cost a teen; How much does it cost to add a teen to car insurance; Safest used cars and what they really cost. How the numbers are calculated is written down on the methodology page, and every source is listed on the sources page.
Definitions
First year total. The car plus one year of running costs. On this page, $17,025 to $17,571: a $12,000 used car plus $5,025 to $5,571 to run it for a year.
Running costs. Insurance, gas, and upkeep together, without the car. On this page, $5,025 to $5,571 a year, or about $419 to $464 a month, and the ongoing figure from year two onward.
Insurance range. The spread between published 2026 teen insurance averages. On this page, $3,048 to $3,594 a year, because no single typical teen insurance figure is universal.
Upkeep. Maintenance costed by the mile. On this page, 7,624 miles at about 11.7 cents a mile, or $892 for the year.
Repair fund. Money set aside on top of the $892 upkeep line for an older first car, since $892 is a planning figure, not a promise that nothing big breaks.
Driver education. The course a state or school may require. It sits outside the total on this page.
Questions people actually ask
What does a teen first year of driving cost, all in?
In the example on this page, $17,025 to $17,571: a $12,000 used car plus $5,025 to $5,571 to run it for a year, made of insurance $3,048 to $3,594, gas $1,085, and upkeep $892. After year one, the ongoing cost is the running costs line, about $419 to $464 a month, since the car is already bought.
Why is teen insurance shown as a range instead of one figure?
Because no single typical teen insurance figure is universal. The Driveonomics first car page uses $3,048 a year from 2026 MoneyGeek averages, while the adding a teen page puts published 2026 averages at $3,435 to $3,594 a year, with $4,050 at age 16 falling to $3,105 at age 19. This page runs from $3,048 to $3,594 and states the disagreement, and your own quote can land outside the range in either direction.
What is not included in the teen first year total?
Sales tax and title, which are one time costs that vary by state, registration, which is paid at purchase and renewed each year at a state dependent amount, a repair fund on top of the $892 upkeep planning figure for an older first car, and driver education where required. Check your state fees before buying.
Does the first year total repeat every year?
No. The $12,000 car is a one time purchase in year one. From year two onward, the cost is the running costs line: insurance, gas, and upkeep, which is $5,025 to $5,571 a year in this example, or about $419 to $464 a month, before any repair fund.
How many miles a year does the example teen drive?
7,624 miles a year, the Federal Highway Administration teen mileage average. At 30 miles per gallon and $4.27 a gallon, that is $1,085 of gas for the year, and at about 11.7 cents a mile, $892 of upkeep.
Related: See how much car insurance costs, the biggest line in a teen's first year.
Related: See whether a second car is worth it for the teen driver.