Page published October 30, 2026
Get the free Car Buyer’s Cheat Sheet, 7 things to know before you sign anything. The numbers that matter, in plain English, on one page.
Join the Driveonomics email list. Occasional useful updates, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.
The comparison below puts every model on the same basis: 12,000 miles a year, gas at $4.153 a gallon (the EIA national average for the week ending November 2, 2026), 7% sales tax as a site example, $900 in title and dealer fees, 10% down, 8% APR over 60 months, and each model insurance and upkeep figures from its own Driveonomics cost page. Five of these models originally used a higher gas price on their own pages; their fuel lines here are recomputed at $4.153 so the comparison is clean, and the totals below are the recomputed totals, not the totals on the model pages.
The 5-year totals, side by side
| Class | Model | Purchase price | 5-year total | About a month |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mid-size | Kia Sorento | $32,390 | $49,916 | $832 |
| Mid-size | Toyota Grand Highlander | $44,130 | $54,037 | $901 |
| Mid-size | Hyundai Santa Fe | $37,590 | $54,452 | $908 |
| Mid-size | Chevrolet Traverse | $40,800 | $57,375 | $956 |
| Mid-size | Hyundai Palisade | $43,540 | $60,537 | $1,009 |
| Mid-size | Toyota Highlander | $43,470 | $61,607 | $1,027 |
| Mid-size | Ford Explorer | $40,260 | $62,052 | $1,034 |
| Mid-size | Kia Telluride | $45,635 | $67,106 | $1,118 |
| Full-size | Ford Expedition | $62,400 | $78,702 | $1,312 |
| Full-size | GMC Yukon | $69,900 | $89,088 | $1,485 |
| Full-size | Chevrolet Tahoe | $68,095 | $90,721 | $1,512 |
Each total is value lost plus insurance plus fuel plus upkeep plus tax plus fees plus loan interest, on the basis stated above. The monthly figure is the 5-year total divided by 60, rounded to the nearest dollar. Averages: eight mid-size models at $58,385, or about $973 a month; three full-size models at $86,170, or about $1,436 a month; a gap of $27,785, or about $463 a month.
Formula
Every row sits on the same basis: 12,000 miles a year, gas at $4.153 a gallon (the EIA national average for the week ending November 2, 2026), 7% sales tax as a site example, $900 in title and dealer fees, 10% down, 8% APR over 60 months, and each model insurance and upkeep figures from its own Driveonomics cost page. Each total is value lost plus insurance plus fuel plus upkeep plus tax plus fees plus loan interest, and the monthly figure is the 5-year total divided by 60, rounded to the nearest dollar. The eight mid-size models average $58,385, or about $973 a month, and the three full-size models average $86,170, or about $1,436 a month, a gap of $27,785, or about $463 a month. The averages check: $58,385 plus $27,785 is $86,170.
The two same-brand pairs keep the brand fixed and move only the size. A Chevrolet Traverse at $57,375 costs $33,346 less over 5 years than a Chevrolet Tahoe at $90,721, or about $556 a month less. A Ford Explorer at $62,052 costs $16,650 less than a Ford Expedition at $78,702, or about $278 a month less. The Chevy step down saves roughly double the Ford step down, because the Tahoe starts much dearer than the Expedition while the Traverse and Explorer start close together. The classes do not overlap on this page: the cheapest full-size, the Expedition at $78,702, still costs $11,596 more than the dearest mid-size, the Telluride at $67,106, and the cheapest mid-size, the Kia Sorento at $49,916, undercuts the cheapest full-size by $28,786.
The gap comes mostly from price and value loss, then fuel. The full-size models start near $62,000 to $70,000, so they lose more dollars even when they lose a similar share, and they carry higher tax and interest on the higher price. Fuel adds to it: the full-size models here run 17 to 19 miles per gallon against 20 to 26 for the mid-size models, so the bigger SUV burns more gallons every year at the same mileage. Insurance and upkeep differ by model but do not drive the class gap the way price and fuel do. Five models originally used a higher gas price on their own pages (Grand Highlander, Traverse, Sorento, Santa Fe, Expedition), so their fuel lines here are recomputed at $4.153 so the comparison is clean, and the totals below are the recomputed totals, not the totals on the model pages.
Same brand, smaller SUV: the two clean pairs
Averages can hide brand differences, so here are the two pairs where the buyer stays with the same brand and only steps down a size. A Chevrolet Traverse at $57,375 costs $33,346 less over 5 years than a Chevrolet Tahoe at $90,721, or about $556 a month less. A Ford Explorer at $62,052 costs $16,650 less than a Ford Expedition at $78,702, or about $278 a month less. The Chevy step down saves roughly double the Ford step down, because the Tahoe starts much dearer than the Expedition while the Traverse and Explorer start close together. Same question, different answer by brand, which is why the pair matters more than the average.
Where the gap actually comes from
Mostly price and value loss, then fuel. The full-size models start near $62,000 to $70,000, so they lose more dollars even when they lose a similar share, and they carry higher tax and interest on the higher price. Fuel adds to it: the full-size models here run 17 to 19 miles per gallon against 20 to 26 for the mid-size models, so the bigger SUV burns more gallons every year at the same mileage. Insurance and upkeep differ by model but do not drive the class gap the way price and fuel do.
One honest point in the full-size favor: the classes do not overlap on this page. The cheapest full-size, the Expedition at $78,702, still costs $11,596 more than the dearest mid-size, the Telluride at $67,106. There is no bargain full-size hiding in this table and no overpriced mid-size crossing over it. If a full-size is what fits your life, no mid-size on this page undercuts it by accident, and the premium is the price of the size itself.
What you give up when you step down
Room and towing, not the third row. A mid-size third row is tighter for adults, there is less cargo space behind it, and towing capacity drops well below what a full-size SUV can pull. For a family hauling kids, gear, and a bike rack, that trade rarely bites. For a family towing a boat or a horse trailer, or carrying adults in the third row every week, it bites hard, and that is the case where the full-size premium earns its keep. Sit every person who will ride in the third row in the mid-size model first, and weigh the heaviest thing you will actually tow, before letting the $27,785 average decide for you.
The question to ask before choosing
Count the weeks the full-size space is actually used, not the space it has. A third row full of adults most weeks, or a trailer hitched most weekends, earns the bigger SUV. A third row full of kids and a cargo area full of sports gear does not need full-size room, and $463 a month is a lot to pay for space that sits empty. Garage fit counts too: a full-size SUV that is a chore to park every day is a cost no total captures.
Still deciding whether you need three rows at all? See do you really need a 3-row SUV. Cross shopping a van instead? See minivan vs 3-row SUV cost. For the family budget version of this question, see family cars under $400 a month, and to run your own numbers on any of these models, use the calculator.
Keep looking
If this page answered one question and raised the next, these follow naturally from it:
- Do you really need a 3-row SUV?: the 3-row vs 2-row version of this question, on the same basis.
- Minivan or 3-row SUV: the van step-down, priced the same way.
- Family cars under $400 a month: when the monthly budget is the binding constraint.
- Check your quote: run a real dealer quote against its own numbers before you sign.
Figures: purchase prices, gas mileage, insurance, upkeep, and value loss from each model own Driveonomics cost page. Fuel recomputed at $4.153 a gallon (the EIA national average for the week ending November 2, 2026) and 12,000 miles a year for every row. Tax at 7% is a site example, not any state actual rate.
Educational estimates only, not financial, tax, legal or insurance advice. Every figure on this page is a typical example worked from the inputs stated on the page, not a quote for a specific car, loan, or driver. Your rate, insurance, fuel use, and resale value will move your total. See Terms.
Calculation transparency
Scope. Eleven three-row SUVs, eight mid-size and three full-size, on one common basis over 5 years, with purchase prices and per-model insurance, upkeep, and value loss from each model own Driveonomics cost page.
Rules and time period. Common basis: 12,000 miles a year; gas at $4.153 a gallon, the EIA national average for the week ending November 2, 2026; 7% sales tax as a site example; $900 in title and dealer fees; 10% down; 8% APR over 60 months; five models fuel recomputed at $4.153; monthly figure is the 5-year total divided by 60, rounded to the nearest dollar; averages are simple averages of the models listed.
Scope and limitations. Educational estimate only. Tax at 7% is a site example, not any state actual rate. Your rate, insurance, fuel use, and resale value will move your total. Room, towing, and garage fit are not in the totals: a mid-size third row is tighter for adults, cargo space behind it is smaller, and towing capacity drops well below what a full-size SUV can pull. Prices vary by car, shop, and city. Get a written quote for your own car before you decide.
Source links checked November 6, 2026. Figures: Purchase prices, gas mileage, insurance, upkeep, and value loss from each model own Driveonomics cost page; fuel recomputed at $4.153 a gallon, the EIA national average for the week ending November 2, 2026, at 12,000 miles a year for every row; tax at 7% is a site example, not any state actual rate.
Primary sources: EIA, U.S. weekly retail gasoline prices; Chevrolet Traverse true cost; Ford Explorer true cost; Minivan or 3-row SUV cost. How the numbers are calculated is written down on the methodology page, and every source is listed on the sources page.
Definitions
Mid-size 3-row SUV. A three-row SUV in the smaller class on this page. Eight models here, averaging $58,385 over 5 years.
Full-size 3-row SUV. A three-row SUV in the larger class on this page. Three models here, averaging $86,170 over 5 years.
Value lost. The value a car loses in dollars over 5 years, the gap between what it cost and what it is worth later. The full-size models lose more dollars because they start dearer.
Upkeep. Maintenance and repairs together, the work that keeps a car running and the fixes when something breaks. On this page, the per-model upkeep figures come from each model own Driveonomics cost page.
APR. Annual percentage rate, the yearly interest rate on the loan. This example uses 8%. For context, Experian reported average rates of 6.35% on new cars and 11.19% on used cars in the second quarter of 2026.
Sales tax. A tax on the purchase price, charged by your state. On this page, 7% is a site example, not any state actual rate.
Third row. The rearmost seats. Every mid-size model on this page has three rows and seats seven or eight. What shrinks when you step down is third-row room, cargo space behind the third row, and towing capacity, not the row itself.
Towing capacity. How much the SUV can pull. A mid-size tows well below what a full-size SUV can pull.
Questions people actually ask
How much more does a full-size 3-row SUV cost than a mid-size one over 5 years?
On the same basis on this page, the eight mid-size 3-row SUVs average $58,385 over 5 years and the three full-size 3-row SUVs average $86,170, a gap of $27,785, or about $463 a month. The gap varies by model: the cheapest mid-size here, the Kia Sorento at $49,916, is $28,786 less than the cheapest full-size here, the Ford Expedition at $78,702.
What is the cheapest mid-size 3-row SUV over 5 years on this page?
The Kia Sorento, at $49,916 over 5 years, or about $832 a month, on a $32,390 purchase price. Next cheapest are the Toyota Grand Highlander at $54,037, the Hyundai Santa Fe at $54,452, and the Chevrolet Traverse at $57,375, then the Hyundai Palisade at $60,537, the Toyota Highlander at $61,607, the Ford Explorer at $62,052, and the Kia Telluride at $67,106.
What is the cheapest full-size 3-row SUV over 5 years on this page?
The Ford Expedition, at $78,702 over 5 years, or about $1,312 a month, on a $62,400 purchase price. Next are the GMC Yukon at $89,088 and the Chevrolet Tahoe at $90,721. Even the cheapest full-size here costs $11,596 more than the dearest mid-size here, the Kia Telluride at $67,106, so on this page the two size classes do not overlap.
Do these totals use the same inputs for every model?
Yes. Every row uses 12,000 miles a year, gas at $4.153 a gallon (the EIA national average for the week ending November 2, 2026), 7% sales tax as a site example, $900 in title and dealer fees, 10% down, 8% APR over 60 months, and the insurance and upkeep figures from that model own Driveonomics cost page. Five models originally used a higher gas price on their own pages (Grand Highlander, Traverse, Sorento, Santa Fe, Expedition), so their fuel lines here are recomputed at $4.153 to keep the comparison clean.
When is the full-size SUV worth the extra money?
When the bigger size is doing real work most weeks: adults riding in the third row, heavy towing, or cargo behind the third row that a mid-size cannot hold. The full-size premium buys room and towing, not a third row itself, since every mid-size model on this page already has three rows. If the third row mostly holds kids and the tow hitch mostly holds a bike rack, the mid-size keeps the seats and drops about $463 a month.
Related: other three-row SUVs in the same lane: Honda Pilot, about $1,064 a month, Dodge Durango, about $912 a month.
Related: minivans in the same lane: Honda Odyssey, about $969 a month and Toyota Sienna, about $946 a month. deciding between them: can a family car fit $400 or $600 a month, what a family road trip costs in gas.